HISTORY LESSONS
  • The Books
  • The Blog
  • The channel
  • Extra Credit
  • Visit Victory Independent Planning

Doolittle’s Dilemma

4/18/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
Synopsis: Recent economic numbers are underwhelming, but confidence surveys are increasingly optimistic. Hard data or soft statistics, which one gives a more reliable picture? A WWII bombing operation might give some insight as to where we are heading and what really matters on your own mission. 

The B-25’s engines droned on and the Pacific slid by two hundred feet below like an endless blue scroll unfurling in front of them. From the cockpit of the lead bomber, the copilot of aircraft number 40-2344, glanced backward over the left and right wings to see a great V shaped wedge of sixteen similar aircraft.  Like migrating geese, he thought.
 
Then the call that made his arms turn to goose flesh: “Bandits, two o’clock high. Looks like they are going away from us.” 
 
“Zeroes.” Someone else in the formation added, indicating that the planes were the formidable Mitsubishi A6Ms.
 
He stared at the enemy formation, willing them to keep moving up and out over the Pacific. Don’t see us. Come on, let us have one break today. Japanese picket vessels had spotted them aboard the USS Hornet early that morning, and though the Navy made quick work in sinking them, it had to be assumed that the carrier’s presence was known and their element of surprise gone. So, the giant Army Air Force bombers lumbered down the flight deck of the Navy’s aircraft carrier twelve hours ahead of schedule. He’d watched the “boat” as the sailors called it, turn hard after the last launch and steam east, back to base. There would be no landings on her deck after this mission. That, he tried hard not to think about. 
 
“They’re turning,” someone announced over the squadron frequency. He tensed and his stomach dropped hundreds of feet to the wave tops below. We aren’t geese… we’re more like sitting ducks. He looked left where his pilot, Jimmy Doolittle, sat looking intently ahead.
 
“No…it was just a sun flash. They are still on the same course,” came a tense, clipped retort. The sun was another issue altogether. The early departure led them to change from a night mission to this assault in broad daylight. But the sun, the mid-day sun, masked them as they flew in from the east. The fighters never saw the formation of bombers, or if they did, assumed them to be Japanese. In moments, they were gone and the great land mass of Honshu Island loomed, a gray brown smudge on the horizon that grew to fill cockpit the around him.
 
Doolittle began a climb to bombing altitude and asked simply: “You ready?”  The copilot, Richard Cole, nodded and began adjusting the propeller pitch and coordinating with the bomb crews. In a few seconds, the plane rocked gently and the first red light illuminated on the panel in front of them. “One away.” Three more quickly followed and in thirty seconds it was all over. Doolittle slammed the throttles forward and dove for the deck, the crew watching as black smoke billowed from their targets, now on fire aft of the right wing. Five months after Pearl Harbor, American forces had struck back, hitting targets in and around Tokyo.
 
Doolittle’s Raiders had about six hours to congratulate themselves, continuing westward toward landing fields in China. Then they either crash landed or bailed out after nightfall. Dick Cole gave himself a black eye pulling on the rip cord on his parachute, was met on the ground by Chinese Nationalist sympathizers and reunited with Doolittle.  Of the eighty men crewing the raid, eight were captured, one died in captivity and three were killed. Doolittle was distraught, believing that the damage done was insignificant and the loss of men and aircraft meant the mission was a failure. 
 
In the card hold arithmetic of war, he was correct. The raid didn’t degrade the enemy’s fighting capabilities much, nor did it permanently damage supplies or material. The hard data would seem to support the pessimistic view. But Doolittle turned out to be wrong. His Raiders were hailed as heroes back home and the mission seen as sending an important mission to the Japanese public. They gave the seemingly invincible forces of the Emperor something to fear. And they gave Americans, still stewing over Pearl Harbor, hope.
 
So, what matters more, hard or soft data? Much of the financial media is asking a similar question today as economic numbers underwhelm, but confidence and survey responses indicate increasingly optimistic sentiment. Here’s how to fly through this tricky period by keeping three things in mind:
 
  1. The hard data isn’t all pessimistic. Despite his misgivings, Doolittle’s raid did have some concrete results, including damage to a ship that was to be converted to an aircraft carrier and was delayed for months. In the Pacific theatre in 1942 one ship could mean quite a bit. Today, in a low growth economy, every measurement also means quite a bit. But one data point doesn’t make a trend any more than one mission wins or loses an entire war. And much of the recent angst is over data showing not decline, but slower than expected growth which is nothing to bail out over.
  2. Sentiment can change the future. The realization by the Japanese public that they were no longer insulated from the war forced the high command to do things differently. In effect, the sentiment forced them to seek a decisive battle sooner than they wanted at the Battle of Midway, where the Americans narrowly prevailed.  Likewise, soft data can change our behavior and pull us in positive or negative directions. Believing things are good can help consumer spending or corporate investment, but won’t show up for a while in the “real” data. Sometimes you have to keep flying forward to find out what is there.
  3. None of this should be scary. Doolittle’s Raid took place seventy-five years ago this month. As of this writing, Dick Cole at age 101, is the only living survivor. He noted that the scariest part of the mission, taking off in a huge bomber from an aircraft carrier designed for smaller planes, turned out to be the easiest. “I was flying with the best pilot, so why worry?” If the seemingly divergent nature of hard and soft data is worrying you, you don’t have the right strategic plan or a steady hand at the controls. If you live to be 101, there will be numerous instances of hard and soft data not seeming to agree and a good financial plan will take those ups and downs into account. So why worry?

Photo: Bing.com Images- Free to Share & Use
Links to Sources:
 
1) The Doolittle Raid, 1942," EyeWitness to History, www.eyewitnesstohistory.com (2007).                                                                                 http://www.eyewitnesstohistory.com/doolittle.html 
2)         http://turningpoint1942.org/doolittle-raid.html 
3)         http://www.cnn.com/2017/04/18/us/75th-anniversary-doolittle-raid/
4)         http://www.doolittleraider.com/80_brave_men.htm
5)         http://www.historynet.com/aftermath-doolittle-raid-reexamined.htm
0 Comments

    RSS Feed

    Don't wait for history to happen...

      Sign up to have your lessons delivered to your inbox.

    Deliver My History Lessons!

    Archives

    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017

    Categories

    All
    ABL
    Action Bias
    Advice
    Advisor
    Anchoring Bias
    Annual Recap
    Astronomy
    Aviation
    Bandwagon Effect
    Baseball
    Broadway
    Bull Market
    China
    Christmas
    Civil War
    Cognitive Bias
    Cold War
    Columbus
    Confirmation Bias
    Corrections
    COVID
    Cyclicality
    DALBAR
    Darwin
    Data
    D Day
    Diversification
    Earnings
    Economics
    Emotions
    Expert
    Expert Bias
    Federal Reserve
    Fiduciary
    Financial Media
    FOMO
    Football
    Founders
    France
    Fund Flows
    GDP
    Gift Planning
    Globalism
    Golf
    Government
    High Jump
    Impressionism
    Inflation
    Interest Rates
    Italy
    January Effect
    Journalism
    Julius Caesar
    Loss Aversion
    Market Timing
    Music
    Normandy
    October
    Oregon State
    Performance
    Pilgrims
    Planning
    Politics
    Prognostication
    Property Rights
    Rationality
    Recency Bias
    Regulation
    Retirement
    Revolutionary War
    Risk
    Roman History
    Santa
    Sell In May
    Sentiment
    Spanish Flu
    Statistics
    Taxes
    Technology
    Tennis
    Trade
    Trade War
    Unintended Consequences
    VIX
    Wall Of Worry
    Wild West
    WW I
    WW II

Patrick Huey is the author of two books:  "History Lessons for the Modern Investor" and "the Seven Pillars of (Financial) Wisdom"; this is considered an outside business activity for Patrick Huey and is separate and apart from his activities as an investment advisor representative with Dynamic Wealth Advisors.  The material contained in these books are the current opinions of the author, Patrick Huey but not necessarily those of Dynamic Wealth Advisors.   The opinions expressed in these books are for general informational purposes only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual or on any specific security. They are intended to provide education about the financial industry. To determine which investments may be appropriate for you, consult your financial advisor prior to investing. Any past performance discussed in these books is no guarantee of future results.  As always please remember investing involves risk and possible loss of principal capital. 
  • The Books
  • The Blog
  • The channel
  • Extra Credit
  • Visit Victory Independent Planning